Publication Ethics

Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement

Introduction

At WISJournal, we guarantee the integrity of our academic content and publishing procedure. Consequently, researchers are urged to align their investigations with established procedures and adhere to a robust code of conduct relevant to the profession or governed by international regulatory authorities.

Research Integrity

We maintain a rigorous standard at WISJournal. Our contributors from many disciplines and institutions are urged to adhere rigorously to the following:

  1. Intellectual integrity in all facets of research.
  2. Comprehensive evaluation, precision, and superiority in research methodology.
  3. Communication of research findings with enhanced transparency and ethical standards.
  4. Respect, consideration, and safeguarding of all participants involved in the study subjects.

Editorial Process

At WISJournal, we are dedicated to ensuring a high standard in the content-creation process, independent of mere facts or information. Our editorial approach is collaboratively effective and of superior quality. Our comprehensive editing policy is delineated as follows:

  1. A preliminary review commences post-submission, and the submission is eligible for peer evaluation only when:
    • The manuscript aligns with the journal's scope;
    • Authorship details are substantiated;
    • The presentation adheres to our selection criteria;
    • Necessary information pertaining to research ethics is incorporated in the manuscript;
    • The manuscript is devoid of plagiarism. Upon submission, qualified and competent reviewers will be solicited to conduct a critical evaluation.
  2. Following a thorough assessment of reviewers' remarks, editors will determine whether to accept or reject the submitted manuscript, or request authors to revise their submissions.
  3. Following an author's revision, reviewers are re-engaged for a further evaluation of the work. By implementing this approach, editors will determine the acceptance or rejection of the amended submission.
  4. If a submission is ultimately accepted, it will undergo layout editing, author proofreading, format conversion, and linguistic structure editing before publishing.

Peer Review

We employ a double-blind peer review process to evaluate submitted publications. The journal performs external peer evaluations, with reviewers independent of the publisher. WISJournal recognises the essential function of critical evaluation in maintaining the integrity of the academic record. Our peer reviewers must follow these essential guidelines:

  • Reviewers should only consent to evaluate papers for which they possess the requisite topic competence and can complete the assessment within an appropriate timeframe.
  • Reviewers must maintain the confidentiality of the peer review process and refrain from disclosing any details of a manuscript or its evaluation during or after the review, save for information disclosed by the journal.
  • Reviewers must not exploit knowledge acquired during the evaluation process to the detriment of others or for personal, third-party, or organisational gain.
  • Reviewers must disclose all potential conflicts of interest and seek guidance from the journal if uncertain about the relevance of a particular interest.
  • Reviewers must ensure their evaluations are not swayed by the manuscript's origin, nationality, religious or political opinions, gender, commercial interests, or any other attributes of the authors.
  • Reviewers must be impartial and constructive in their evaluations, refraining from antagonism, provocation, or defamatory personal remarks.
  • Reviewers must recognise that peer review is fundamentally a reciprocal undertaking and should strive to fulfil their equitable portion of reviews in a timely manner.
  • Reviewers must provide the journal with accurate personal and professional information that authentically reflects their expertise.
  • Reviewers must recognise that impersonating another individual during the review process is a grave offence.

Special Issue Policy

WISJournal has no tradition of publishing special issues.

Authorship

Any scholarly contribution to the development and conclusion of research carries substantial academic implications. This indicates that published works entail authorship accompanied by liability and accountability. When recruiting authors for research endeavours, prospective authors must be familiar with the following:

  • Individuals who have made significant contributions to the conception, design, data gathering, analysis, interpretation, and drafting or modification of the work must be acknowledged as authors.
  • The role of the corresponding author is not superior to that of other authors or collaborators; instead, the corresponding author bears the main responsibility for communication with the journal throughout submission, peer review, and publication.
  • For persons whose contributions do not warrant authorship (e.g., data collectors, data managers, professional writing assistance), a brief acknowledgement section should recognise their efforts during the study process.

Plagiarism

We use Turnitin to evaluate all manuscripts submitted to WISJournal. Employing another author's words, ideas, sentiments, or concepts as one's own unique work is unequivocally wrong. The greatest acceptable originality threshold for a manuscript at WISJournal is 20% or below. Self-plagiarism is also regarded as an offence — this occurs when an author uses a substantial portion of their previously published work without appropriate citation, alters a previously published manuscript, or disseminates the identical work across multiple journals. To address this, authors are recommended to:

  • Refrain from exact replication of another individual's work where appropriate attribution to the author or source is unfeasible;
  • Eschew rearranging, rewording, or paraphrasing another's ideas or work without proper citation of the source;
  • Avoid employing the works or ideas of individuals from the internet to create imitations of online sources;
  • Refrain from incorporating the works of other authors into one's own without proper acknowledgement of the original author.

Generative AI Use

The journal has adopted and modified the Generative AI policies of Elsevier (elsevier.com/about/policies-and-standards/generative-ai-policies-for-journals).

For Authors

  • WISJournal's AI strategy pertains only to the writing phase and does not encompass the use of AI tools for data analysis and insight generation within the research process.
  • Authors are prohibited from using AI to produce their manuscripts; they must compose them independently.
  • Where authors employ generative AI and AI-assisted technologies in the writing process, such technologies should solely be used to enhance the readability and language of the work. AI implementation necessitates human monitoring and control, and authors must meticulously evaluate and edit the outcomes, as AI can produce authoritative-sounding content that may be erroneous, incomplete, or biased.
  • Authors bear ultimate responsibility and accountability for the work's contents.
  • Authors must refrain from listing AI or AI-assisted technologies as authors or co-authors, or citing AI as an author. Authorship entails responsibilities exclusively assignable to and executable by humans.
  • Each (co-)author is responsible for ensuring that enquiries concerning the correctness or integrity of any aspect of the work are thoroughly investigated and addressed. Authorship requires the capacity to endorse the final version of the work and consent to its submission.

Use of Generative AI in Figures, Images, and Artwork

  • Authors are prohibited from using Generative AI or AI-assisted methods to generate or modify images in submitted publications — including augmenting, concealing, relocating, eliminating, or incorporating elements into an image or figure.
  • Modifications to brightness, contrast, or colour balance are permissible provided they do not obscure or erase information in the original. Image forensics tools may be used to detect anomalies. The sole exception occurs where AI tools are integral to the research design or methodology itself (e.g., AI-assisted biomedical imaging); such use must be described in a replicable fashion in the methods section, including the model or tool, version, and manufacturer.
  • Authors must comply with the specific usage policies of the AI software and ensure accurate content attribution, and may be asked to supply pre-AI-modified images for editorial evaluation. Generative AI use in graphical abstracts is prohibited. Use of generative AI for cover art may be permitted with prior consent from the journal editor and publisher, provided all requisite rights are secured and attribution is guaranteed.

For Reviewers

  • A manuscript under review must be regarded as confidential.
  • Reviewers must refrain from uploading a submitted manuscript, or any portion thereof, into a generative AI tool, as this could infringe on authors' confidentiality and property rights and may violate data privacy rights.
  • This confidentiality obligation extends to the peer review report itself; reviewers must not input their reports into an AI tool, even to enhance language and readability.
  • Evaluating a scientific publication entails obligations solely assignable to humans.
  • Reviewers must refrain from employing generative AI or AI-assisted technologies in the scientific review of a manuscript, as the requisite critical thinking exceeds the capabilities of this technology. The reviewer is liable for the content of the review report.

For Editors

  • A submitted manuscript is a confidential document. Editors must refrain from uploading a submitted manuscript, or any portion thereof, into a generative AI tool.
  • This confidentiality obligation encompasses all correspondence relating to the manuscript, including notice or decision letters; editors should not upload these to an AI tool, even for the purpose of enhancing language and readability.
  • Overseeing the editorial assessment of a scientific publication entails obligations exclusively assignable to humans. Editors must refrain from using generative AI or AI-assisted technologies in the evaluation or decision-making processes regarding manuscripts.
  • The editor is responsible for the editorial process, the final decision, and the communication of that decision to the authors.
Average time from submission to publication: approximately 12 weeks.

Research with Animals or Humans

Studies involving animals or humans must undergo thorough evaluation and receive approval from an Institutional Review Board (IRB) prior to commencement. The privacy rights of study subjects and participants must be upheld, and informed consent must be acquired from subjects who have agreed to participate. Authors must recognise that informed consent is not merely a signed document but a comprehensive procedure whereby subjects comprehend their responsibilities, the objectives, and the associated risks of the research.

Research Involving Vulnerable Groups

WISJournal mandates the consideration of specific factors in studies involving vulnerable populations:

  • In research involving minors (individuals under 18 years), parental or guardian consent is required for participation.
  • The vulnerable group and its parents or guardians must comprehend the full ramifications of their participation in the study.
  • They must also provide consent for the study's publication.
  • Authors must furnish proof that the above ethical standards were satisfied.

Conflicts of Interest (COI) and Funding

At WISJournal, one of our objectives is to guarantee that publications are devoid of excessive influence. We expect authors to declare:

  • All financial conflicts of interest, without temporal constraints.
  • Pertinent non-financial possible conflicts of interest.

Libel, Defamation, and Freedom of Expression

We condemn any type of deceptive publication or assertion that jeopardises the reputation of persons, groups, or organisations. Should such a circumstance occur, our legal team will respond accordingly.

Retractions, Corrections, and Expressions of Concern

WISJournal advocates for the retraction, correction, and expression of concern over published publications. A retraction may be initiated by our editors, the authors of the publication, or their institution. In infrequent instances, retraction is accompanied by an apology for the prior mistake and/or acknowledgement of individuals who informed the author of the error. A similar expression of concern is advised as with retraction or correction.

Falsification, Fabrication, and Image Manipulation

We acknowledge that the results of data collected or depicted as visuals may be misleading if not suitably adjusted. We therefore recommend that authors take a critical approach when altering data obtained in this manner. A thorough examination of altering such images is essential to avert falsification, fabrication, or misrepresentation of outcomes.

Fraudulent Research and Research Misconduct

Upon the discovery of fraudulent research or research misconduct by an author, we will engage with the relevant editor(s) and other relevant institutions or organisations for investigation. Any publication identified as containing false content will be retracted, or a suitable correction or expression of concern shall be given.

Data and Supporting Evidence

Authors are urged to maintain transparency concerning data coding and the resources utilised throughout the research process. Writers are required to furnish and retain precise data and corroborative evidence pertinent to their research in a repository or storage facility, to facilitate verification, comprehension, and potential duplication of findings by others.

Copyright and License

By submitting papers to WISJournal, contributors consent to the following terms:

  • Copyright for articles published by WISJournal is kept by the author(s).
  • By submitting manuscripts to the journal, authors confer upon WISJournal a license to publish the articles and designate itself as the original publisher.
  • Authors also permit any third party to freely use the article, provided its integrity is maintained and the original authors, citation details, and publisher are distinctly acknowledged.
  • When an author is prohibited from retaining copyright, small modifications may be necessary; authors requiring such adjustments must notify the WISJournal editorial team post-acceptance.

License Agreement

By submitting an article to WISJournal, the corresponding author affirms that:

  • They are authorised by co-authors to enter into this agreement.
  • The article is original, has not been previously published in any other peer-reviewed journal, is not currently under consideration elsewhere, and does not violate any existing copyright or third-party rights.
  • The author(s) are the sole author(s) of the article and possess full authority to enter into this agreement, granting rights to WISJournal without breaching any other obligation.
  • The article contains no unlawful or libellous content, nor does it, if published, breach any contract, confidentiality, or secrecy commitment.
  • Due diligence has been exercised to ensure the article's integrity; to the authors' present scientific understanding, all factual assertions are truthful, and any formula or instruction provided will not, if executed precisely, result in injury, illness, or harm to the user.
  • All co-authors concur that the paper, if accepted, shall be licensed in accordance with WISJournal standards.
Important: Regardless of whether authors complete a form, the license agreement applies to all papers published by the journal. Authors should review the license agreement prior to submitting their work.

Licensing

All articles disseminated by WISJournal are licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC-SA). Through non-commercial use of works published by WISJournal, readers are permitted to read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, or link to the complete texts of published articles, and may employ them for any other permissible reason. Readers must appropriately acknowledge sources.

Archiving Policy

  • The journal permits authors to archive their articles on personal or corporate websites and/or to use the final published version for institutional repository archiving post-publication.
  • Authors may self-archive their papers in public and/or commercial subject-specific repositories.
  • Authors are not bound by an embargo; nonetheless, the published source must be cited, and a link to the article's URL in the journal should be included.
  • Authors may download the manuscript as a PDF and distribute copies to colleagues without restriction.
  • Articles published in our journal are digitally stored on the journal's website and the PKP Preservation Network (PN), as well as on LOCKSS and CLOCKSS platforms.

Version Published in the Journal

Publication Type
Open Access
Distribution and Archiving
PKP Preservation Network (PN), LOCKSS and CLOCKSS
Embargo Period
None
Open Access License
CC BY-NC-SA
Copyright Holder
The author(s)
Archive Location
Journal website, institutional repository, institutional website, author's personal site, public and/or non-commercial subject-specific archives
Policy Conditions
The journal must be cited in accordance with established citation rules and linked to the publisher's version.

The Accepted Version (after peer review)

Embargo Period
None
Archive Location
Journal website, institutional site, author's personal website, public and/or non-commercial subject-specific archives
Copyright Owner
The author(s)

The Initial Manuscript Submitted to the Journal

Embargo Period
None
Archive Location
Journal website and any other non-publicly accessible locations, to avoid being flagged for plagiarism

Repository Policy

Authors may deposit their works in their preferred institutional repository, contingent upon the version of the work. The three variations are described below:

Submitted Version

Submitted versions must not be archived in an online repository, to prevent them being flagged for plagiarism during the editorial team's plagiarism assessments.

Accepted Version (Author Accepted Manuscript)

An accepted paper may be deposited in an institutional repository or any repository selected by the author.

Published Version (Version of Record)

Accepted manuscripts may be archived in institutional repositories, the author's personal websites, and public, non-commercial subject-specific repositories.